The Innsmouth Case is a unique but unorthodox adaptation of the iconic story by H.P. Lovecraft. The team at RobotPumpkin Games has opted for a more lighthearted look, compared to the standard grim atmosphere. The result being a more humorous experience.

While a departure from the norm, it actually works out in its favor. This is made possible by visual design and sense of humor grounded in the world of Lovecraft. Despite its change in tone, The Innsmouth Case is truly made for fans of the horror icon.

Welcome to Innsmouth

Players take on the role of a private detective who has hit rock bottom. In desperate need of work, you take the case of locating a missing girl in the town of Innsmouth. Upon arrival, it’s obvious that something is odd about this community. You must try to find the missing girl and try to survive the night.

The Innsmouth Case is a unique take on a classic story thanks to the artistic choices and sense of humor. While keeping the macabre style, a lighthearted touch up is given to make it more welcoming. One could easily describe it as an adaptation on par with the work of Tim Burton.

The gameplay is that of a visual novel with a good number of branching narrative paths. Your actions and responses will determine the path taken and the result of your playthrough. A journey could be long or short, but you’re encouraged to go back and try again. Thanks to the many narrative paths, players will be coming back for more.

All Praise Dagon

The Innsmouth Case major problem has less to do with the story and more with the delivery. That is because the game feels less like a visual novel and more like an E-book. This has been made possible by the fact that its text heavy but no narration. Not helping is that the text is more dominating while the visuals are almost given a backseat.

This is not to say that this is a boring a game. Its humorous writing along with the rich replay value and respect for the source material makes it ideal for Lovecraft fans. Be aware, this is not a horror game. There are no frights or moments of suspense. It’s a radical departure from the norm but it makes up for it with the humor.

Case Closed

With an emphasis on macabre humor, The Innsmouth Case is a unique adaptation of the iconic story by H.P. Lovecraft. It’s not an adaptation most fans are use to but it will be one that they will enjoy.

Disclaimer: UberStrategist provided the game used in this review.

This review is the critic and thoughts of one writer. If you want to see how other critics felt then check it out on OpenCritic.

8Bit/Digi is an independent media outlet that highlights the video game community and industry of the San Francisco Bay Area.

Help Support 8Bit/Digi

We are an indie media outlet that provides an insight into the gaming community and industry of the Bay Area. Please help support independent media by donating today.


The Innsmouth Case (PC)





  • A unique take on a classic story.
  • Its sense of humor.
  • The artistic choices with the visual design.
  • The many narrative paths one could take.


  • Lacks narration
  • Feels more like an E-book than a visual novel.
  • The visual design is not properly utilized.

Leave a Reply