How Our Score Works

Every 8Bit/Digi review ends with a score on a scale of 1 to 10 that reflects hours spent with a game, anime season, or movie then weighing what it promises against what it delivers. We want you to know what a score means before you spend your money or your weekend.

Review Scale Breakdown

The scale below breaks down each tier so you can read our verdicts at a glance and decide for yourself.

10 = Masterpiece: The best of the best. Any flaws are so minor they do not matter. We either binged most of the season or played for hours without noticing.

9 to 8 = Excellent: An outstanding experience with only a few rough edges. Easy to recommend to almost anyone.

7 = Good: Its flaws are hard to overlook, but it is still fun overall.

6 to 5 = OK: Fun in spots but uneven. Worth playing or watching if the premise grabs you.

4 = Meh!: Still playable or watchable, but poor execution undercuts its best ideas and the flaws pile up.

3 to 2 = Disappointing: Some promise buried under serious problems. Most people should skip it.

1 = Terrible: Low effort, or the people behind it did not even try. It often repeats mistakes others already learned from. For a series, it means we stopped watching after a few episodes because it was unwatchable.

How We Review

For video games, our critics play long enough to form a complete opinion. How much of a game they must finish depends on its length and genre. For example, critics must finish the campaign of a game like Call of Duty, since it is short, and they must also put at least 10 hours into multiplayer, since the series centers on it. For a story-driven RPG like Persona 5, critics must put in at least 50 hours before writing the review. We make exceptions if a game is clearly broken and progression is not possible.

Each review notes the platform the game was played on and whether a publisher or PR firm provided it. DLC and expansions are reviewed and scored on their own. Early access games do not receive a final score until their full release.

For anime, movies, comics, and manga, critics must finish the work at least once before writing their review.

Rescore

Once a review is published, its score is final, with one exception. If our reviewer missed something that would have improved the overall experience, we will revise the score. If a major update significantly changes a game, we may publish a new review instead, because at that point it has become a new game and deserves to be judged as one.

8Bit/Digi provides insightful reviews for Bay Area gamers, anime fans, cosplayers, and movie fans.